Anyone else done judging? I think Mike is waiting for us to finish
Well I manage to vote for some of Lunar 2 and all of Lunar 3.. I can't get on till this weekend because of how busy I've been.
Mike is waiting for you Lily!
;-; ITs not my fault! ZoZo might have not voted either! She hasn't been on because of some reason. I can't contact her on discord either cause her mom took her phone. .-.
Well ZoZo is on discord rn.. asking her about it :P EDIT: So I have a update from ZoZo. Its mainly for @mikelaurence though. Apparently she quit DW around a week ago and she told me to tell Mike this "I have quit Deepworld like a week now so, I want you to pick another judge not by me so, I’ll like you the other people that they want to judge I mean I been busy for weeks now for school. If you need any questions, I would like to ask but please choose one person anybody except you chose some other people for judges! Thank you for you understanding this! By .ZoZo." Didn't make sense though.. But to sum it up she wanted you to choose someone else to replace her or just continue on without her. But if you have any questions for her I can tell her on discord if you would like.
Glad to see there are more judges. Hoping that this could end less than a month. Good luck to all!
4
mikelaurenceNew York CityMember, AdministratorPosts: 5,135
edited February 14
Ok folks, the judges have performed their duties, and we're off to the races with a final 24 entries! Here they are -- I'll try and get the entry numbers soon, but if anyone else has a few minutes to collect them, please do and post them here!
Lunar One - Dalts Lunar One - Mihir Lunar One - Chuuya Lunar One - Gerolo Lunar One - TealHyena Lunar One - PIPTR0 Lunar One - Danno69 Lunar One - Gilby Lunar One - Valriq Lunar One - vmh20 Lunar One - Chromosome Lunar One - Salva Lunar One - Sir_Athur_Dent Lunar One - CerealKiller Lunar One - Meno_191 Lunar Two - racerdog Lunar Two - Sir_Adder Lunar Two - detech Lunar Two - fredwardthegreat Lunar Two - Schara Lunar Two - IronManArcher Lunar Two - XX_UberHunter_XX Lunar Two - Cattsworth Lunar Three - de03
9
mikelaurenceNew York CityMember, AdministratorPosts: 5,135
(If you get ahead of yourself, just remember you have TEN VOTES that you can cast across all these entries. But like I said, we'll get those entry numbers soon so it's easier to check them all out!)
Ok folks, the judges have performed their duties, and we're off to the races with a final 24 entries! Here they are -- I'll try and get the entry numbers soon, but if anyone else has a few minutes to collect them, please do and post them here!
Lunar One - Dalts Lunar One - Mihir Lunar One - Chuuya Lunar One - Gerolo Lunar One - TealHyena Lunar One - PIPTR0 Lunar One - Danno69 Lunar One - Gilby Lunar One - Valriq Lunar One - vmh20 Lunar One - Chromosome Lunar One - Salva Lunar One - Sir_Athur_Dent Lunar One - CerealKiller Lunar One - Meno_191 Lunar Two - racerdog Lunar Two - Sir_Adder Lunar Two - detech Lunar Two - fredwardthegreat Lunar Two - Schara Lunar Two - IronManArcher Lunar Two - XX_UberHunter_XX Lunar Two - Cattsworth Lunar Three - de03
You said the de’s were your alts earlier. It’s also an unfair advantage to use alts, therefore it’s technically cheating.
Wild accusations. I don't recollect saying anything of the sort. Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
You said the de’s were your alts earlier. It’s also an unfair advantage to use alts, therefore it’s technically cheating.
Wild accusations. I don't recollect saying anything of the sort. Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
You said the de’s were your alts earlier. It’s also an unfair advantage to use alts, therefore it’s technically cheating.
Wild accusations. I don't recollect saying anything of the sort. Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
De02, De03, how many alts did you enter?
I don’t think there is a de01. I checked. So just those two.
You said the de’s were your alts earlier. It’s also an unfair advantage to use alts, therefore it’s technically cheating.
Wild accusations. I don't recollect saying anything of the sort. Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
You said the de’s were your alts earlier. It’s also an unfair advantage to use alts, therefore it’s technically cheating.
Wild accusations. I don't recollect saying anything of the sort. Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
De02, De03, how many alts did you enter?
I don’t think there is a de01. I checked. So just those two.
Who are these De guys? I say we disqualify them just for having similar names!
I am pissed of, I think someone is unpurposely making these names and building well just to make me look bad!
You said the de’s were your alts earlier. It’s also an unfair advantage to use alts, therefore it’s technically cheating.
Wild accusations. I don't recollect saying anything of the sort. Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
De02, De03, how many alts did you enter?
I don’t think there is a de01. I checked. So just those two.
Who are these De guys? I say we disqualify them just for having similar names!
I am pissed of, I think someone is unpurposely making these names and building well just to make me look bad!
Detech, I am searching for your comment as we speak. Don’t you worry, all of the de’s will probably be disqualified. All of the players starting with de, I mean.
I reviewed all eligible Lunar One entries, here's the list of them if anyone needs it: Entry ......
This is an unbiased list, I didn't bother looking at names or any of that, just typed numbers from 1++ to 130 and those were the only ones I found had followed the rules. I'll leave the judging part up to the Lunar One judges, I casted my nomination there and so that anyone there reviewing doesn't have to type 130 numbers just check the listed numbers instead. Everything I left out was not following rules or just blatantly abandoned / turned into advertising and wouldn't be possible to make into a dungeon. Hope this helps.
I voted for 10 entries out of your list and for 18 that we’re not in your list.
I would strongly suggest that all judges look at ALL entries and judge for themselves. That would be the most unbiased thing to do in my opinion.
When I am judging I ask myself: “is this something I want to come across while mining?” “Does this ad anything to dw?”
Since we already have tons of regular dungeons, maybe it’s time to ad some creativity?
You also have to take in mind what items they’ve used to build it. If you vote for a crystal block spaceship, it probably won’t be added into the game due to it being expensive. If you also vote for a cool dungeon with teslas and control panels, those also won’t be added due to the craftability and rarity of those items.
I did vote for a few entries that had a Tesla or a few cry blocks. I am sure they could be taken out and it wouldn't effect it that much.
I mean would you really not vote for a dungeon because it has a Tesla? Come on!
For example, i wrote on my entry that jets could be replaced with vats if jets are not to be common items for space.
What I am more worried about is dungeons with a few rooms and no backdrop, or one tone backdrop everywhere and nothing else kn it, no pipes, no decorations at all...
But obviously I wouldn't vote for that 'de' guy's spaceship in lunar two, he's just showing off ... that's just silly...
Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
I reviewed all eligible Lunar One entries, here's the list of them if anyone needs it: Entry ......
This is an unbiased list, I didn't bother looking at names or any of that, just typed numbers from 1++ to 130 and those were the only ones I found had followed the rules. I'll leave the judging part up to the Lunar One judges, I casted my nomination there and so that anyone there reviewing doesn't have to type 130 numbers just check the listed numbers instead. Everything I left out was not following rules or just blatantly abandoned / turned into advertising and wouldn't be possible to make into a dungeon. Hope this helps.
I voted for 10 entries out of your list and for 18 that we’re not in your list.
I would strongly suggest that all judges look at ALL entries and judge for themselves. That would be the most unbiased thing to do in my opinion.
When I am judging I ask myself: “is this something I want to come across while mining?” “Does this ad anything to dw?”
Since we already have tons of regular dungeons, maybe it’s time to ad some creativity?
You also have to take in mind what items they’ve used to build it. If you vote for a crystal block spaceship, it probably won’t be added into the game due to it being expensive. If you also vote for a cool dungeon with teslas and control panels, those also won’t be added due to the craftability and rarity of those items.
I did vote for a few entries that had a Tesla or a few cry blocks. I am sure they could be taken out and it wouldn't effect it that much.
I mean would you really not vote for a dungeon because it has a Tesla? Come on!
For example, i wrote on my entry that jets could be replaced with vats if jets are not to be common items for space.
What I am more worried about is dungeons with a few rooms and no backdrop, or one tone backdrop everywhere and nothing else kn it, no pipes, no decorations at all...
But obviously I wouldn't vote for that 'de' guy's spaceship in lunar two, he's just showing off ... that's just silly...
Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
Man are you guys jumping the gun when a good repped player gets accused? If he says they are not him, believe him
I reviewed all eligible Lunar One entries, here's the list of them if anyone needs it: Entry ......
This is an unbiased list, I didn't bother looking at names or any of that, just typed numbers from 1++ to 130 and those were the only ones I found had followed the rules. I'll leave the judging part up to the Lunar One judges, I casted my nomination there and so that anyone there reviewing doesn't have to type 130 numbers just check the listed numbers instead. Everything I left out was not following rules or just blatantly abandoned / turned into advertising and wouldn't be possible to make into a dungeon. Hope this helps.
I voted for 10 entries out of your list and for 18 that we’re not in your list.
I would strongly suggest that all judges look at ALL entries and judge for themselves. That would be the most unbiased thing to do in my opinion.
When I am judging I ask myself: “is this something I want to come across while mining?” “Does this ad anything to dw?”
Since we already have tons of regular dungeons, maybe it’s time to ad some creativity?
You also have to take in mind what items they’ve used to build it. If you vote for a crystal block spaceship, it probably won’t be added into the game due to it being expensive. If you also vote for a cool dungeon with teslas and control panels, those also won’t be added due to the craftability and rarity of those items.
I did vote for a few entries that had a Tesla or a few cry blocks. I am sure they could be taken out and it wouldn't effect it that much.
I mean would you really not vote for a dungeon because it has a Tesla? Come on!
For example, i wrote on my entry that jets could be replaced with vats if jets are not to be common items for space.
What I am more worried about is dungeons with a few rooms and no backdrop, or one tone backdrop everywhere and nothing else kn it, no pipes, no decorations at all...
But obviously I wouldn't vote for that 'de' guy's spaceship in lunar two, he's just showing off ... that's just silly...
Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
Man are you guys jumping the gun when a good repped player gets accused? If he says they are not him, believe him
I reviewed all eligible Lunar One entries, here's the list of them if anyone needs it: Entry ......
This is an unbiased list, I didn't bother looking at names or any of that, just typed numbers from 1++ to 130 and those were the only ones I found had followed the rules. I'll leave the judging part up to the Lunar One judges, I casted my nomination there and so that anyone there reviewing doesn't have to type 130 numbers just check the listed numbers instead. Everything I left out was not following rules or just blatantly abandoned / turned into advertising and wouldn't be possible to make into a dungeon. Hope this helps.
I voted for 10 entries out of your list and for 18 that we’re not in your list.
I would strongly suggest that all judges look at ALL entries and judge for themselves. That would be the most unbiased thing to do in my opinion.
When I am judging I ask myself: “is this something I want to come across while mining?” “Does this ad anything to dw?”
Since we already have tons of regular dungeons, maybe it’s time to ad some creativity?
You also have to take in mind what items they’ve used to build it. If you vote for a crystal block spaceship, it probably won’t be added into the game due to it being expensive. If you also vote for a cool dungeon with teslas and control panels, those also won’t be added due to the craftability and rarity of those items.
I did vote for a few entries that had a Tesla or a few cry blocks. I am sure they could be taken out and it wouldn't effect it that much.
I mean would you really not vote for a dungeon because it has a Tesla? Come on!
For example, i wrote on my entry that jets could be replaced with vats if jets are not to be common items for space.
What I am more worried about is dungeons with a few rooms and no backdrop, or one tone backdrop everywhere and nothing else kn it, no pipes, no decorations at all...
But obviously I wouldn't vote for that 'de' guy's spaceship in lunar two, he's just showing off ... that's just silly...
Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
Man are you guys jumping the gun when a good repped player gets accused? If he says they are not him, believe him
Anything is possible.
IMO, I think it’s someone trying to get detech in trouble. It doesn’t really matter though. Those two accounts are probably the same person and should be disqualified.
I reviewed all eligible Lunar One entries, here's the list of them if anyone needs it: Entry ......
This is an unbiased list, I didn't bother looking at names or any of that, just typed numbers from 1++ to 130 and those were the only ones I found had followed the rules. I'll leave the judging part up to the Lunar One judges, I casted my nomination there and so that anyone there reviewing doesn't have to type 130 numbers just check the listed numbers instead. Everything I left out was not following rules or just blatantly abandoned / turned into advertising and wouldn't be possible to make into a dungeon. Hope this helps.
I voted for 10 entries out of your list and for 18 that we’re not in your list.
I would strongly suggest that all judges look at ALL entries and judge for themselves. That would be the most unbiased thing to do in my opinion.
When I am judging I ask myself: “is this something I want to come across while mining?” “Does this ad anything to dw?”
Since we already have tons of regular dungeons, maybe it’s time to ad some creativity?
You also have to take in mind what items they’ve used to build it. If you vote for a crystal block spaceship, it probably won’t be added into the game due to it being expensive. If you also vote for a cool dungeon with teslas and control panels, those also won’t be added due to the craftability and rarity of those items.
I did vote for a few entries that had a Tesla or a few cry blocks. I am sure they could be taken out and it wouldn't effect it that much.
I mean would you really not vote for a dungeon because it has a Tesla? Come on!
For example, i wrote on my entry that jets could be replaced with vats if jets are not to be common items for space.
What I am more worried about is dungeons with a few rooms and no backdrop, or one tone backdrop everywhere and nothing else kn it, no pipes, no decorations at all...
But obviously I wouldn't vote for that 'de' guy's spaceship in lunar two, he's just showing off ... that's just silly...
Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
Man are you guys jumping the gun when a good repped player gets accused? If he says they are not him, believe him
You don’t see it?
Not rock solid evidence but it is making me skeptical.
Edited: also I think there’s a comment somewhere in which he asks if alt entries are permitted.
I reviewed all eligible Lunar One entries, here's the list of them if anyone needs it: Entry ......
This is an unbiased list, I didn't bother looking at names or any of that, just typed numbers from 1++ to 130 and those were the only ones I found had followed the rules. I'll leave the judging part up to the Lunar One judges, I casted my nomination there and so that anyone there reviewing doesn't have to type 130 numbers just check the listed numbers instead. Everything I left out was not following rules or just blatantly abandoned / turned into advertising and wouldn't be possible to make into a dungeon. Hope this helps.
I voted for 10 entries out of your list and for 18 that we’re not in your list.
I would strongly suggest that all judges look at ALL entries and judge for themselves. That would be the most unbiased thing to do in my opinion.
When I am judging I ask myself: “is this something I want to come across while mining?” “Does this ad anything to dw?”
Since we already have tons of regular dungeons, maybe it’s time to ad some creativity?
You also have to take in mind what items they’ve used to build it. If you vote for a crystal block spaceship, it probably won’t be added into the game due to it being expensive. If you also vote for a cool dungeon with teslas and control panels, those also won’t be added due to the craftability and rarity of those items.
I did vote for a few entries that had a Tesla or a few cry blocks. I am sure they could be taken out and it wouldn't effect it that much.
I mean would you really not vote for a dungeon because it has a Tesla? Come on!
For example, i wrote on my entry that jets could be replaced with vats if jets are not to be common items for space.
What I am more worried about is dungeons with a few rooms and no backdrop, or one tone backdrop everywhere and nothing else kn it, no pipes, no decorations at all...
But obviously I wouldn't vote for that 'de' guy's spaceship in lunar two, he's just showing off ... that's just silly...
Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
Man are you guys jumping the gun when a good repped player gets accused? If he says they are not him, believe him
You don’t see it?
Three dots is your conviction? ...that's just silly...
But on another note, if I saw a player make multiple good entries and take the effort of transfering building mats to alts. .. I'd think, maybe he was trying to add some good content to the game. So I wouldn't be so ruff on these guys, especially considering how many people didn't put any effort into their entries.
Comments
EDIT: So I have a update from ZoZo. Its mainly for @mikelaurence though. Apparently she quit DW around a week ago and she told me to tell Mike this "I have quit Deepworld like a week now so, I want you to pick another judge not by me so, I’ll like you the other people that they want to judge I mean I been busy for weeks now for school. If you need any questions, I would like to ask but please choose one person anybody except you chose some other people for judges! Thank you for you understanding this! By .ZoZo." Didn't make sense though..
But to sum it up she wanted you to choose someone else to replace her or just continue on without her. But if you have any questions for her I can tell her on discord if you would like.
(Lunar One)
Dalts - 54
Mihir - 15
Chuuya - 37
PIPTR0 - 91
Gilby - 34
vmh20 - 9
CerealKiller - 75
Meno_191 - 101
(Lunar Two)
Racerdog - 2
Sir_Adder - 1
Detech - 21
IronManArcher - 67
XX_UberHunter_XX - 111
Cattsworth - 118
That's all I have, I'm missing quite a few but I got all of these from the list on the competition pro number thread.
Here is everyone else:
Lunar One, Entry 54 - Dalts
Lunar One, Entry 15 - Mihir
Lunar One, Entry 37 - Chuuya
Lunar One, Entry 43 - Gerolo
Lunar One, Entry 87 - TealHyena
Lunar One, Entry 91 - PIPTR0
Lunar One, Entry 104 - Danno69
Lunar One, Entry 34 - Gilby
Lunar One, Entry 7 - Valriq
Lunar One, Entry 9 - vmh20
Lunar One, Entry 26 - Chromosome
Lunar One, Entry ??? - Salva
Lunar One, Entry 60 - Sir_Athur_Dent
Lunar One, Entry 75 - CerealKiller
Lunar One, Entry 101 - Meno_191
Lunar Two, Entry 2 - racerdog
Lunar Two, Entry 1 - Sir_Adder
Lunar Two, Entry 21 - detech
Lunar Two, Entry 34 - fredwardthegreat
Lunar Two, Entry 38 - Schara
Lunar Two, Entry 67 - IronManArcher
Lunar Two, Entry 111 - XX_UberHunter_XX
Lunar Two, Entry 118 - Cattsworth
Lunar Three, Entry 1 - de03
I don't recollect saying anything of the sort.
Maybe you spoke to this de guy and he said something to you? I am not responsible for that others say. But if you accuse me of cheating, please provide proof.
I am pissed of, I think someone is unpurposely making these names and building well just to make me look bad!
Got it! Page two of the POST YOUR PRO NUMBER discussion states that you are in fact the de’s. By adding those dot dot dots, that means you were also hinting towards it right there. Just fully admit that they’re yours, then your reputation can remain unscathed.
IMO, I think it’s someone trying to get detech in trouble. It doesn’t really matter though. Those two accounts are probably the same person and should be disqualified.
Edited: also I think there’s a comment somewhere in which he asks if alt entries are permitted.
But on another note, if I saw a player make multiple good entries and take the effort of transfering building mats to alts. .. I'd think, maybe he was trying to add some good content to the game. So I wouldn't be so ruff on these guys, especially considering how many people didn't put any effort into their entries.
Just a thought.