Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

Our latest update has been released! Please leave us a nice review in the App Store if you have the time, thank you!

COMPETITION: Space Spawn

178101213

Comments

  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Detech said:

    Instead of arguing regarding what items should or should not be used, I decided to write down an expanded note for judges (and contestants). Please let me know if you agree or disagree on any parts:

    Judging Space Spawn Competition:
    1-10/10 Creativity & Attractiveness
    1-10/10 Originality & Style
    1-10/10 Space Look
    1-10/10 Usability
    4-40/40 TOTAL

    Creativity & Attractiveness:
    This part of judging depends solely on how much the judge likes your build.
    How creative does the judge think your build is and how much does he like it?

    Originality & Style:
    Does the entry have a certain style to it?
    Does it stand out from the rest? From what you usually see in deepworld?
    Will the entry add something new to deepworld and inspire others to build and create?
    Is there a pattern in the entry, or is it messy?
    Does the style hold throughout the whole entry?

    Space Look:
    Does the entry look like it belongs in space?
    Entries can be out of any material, but should look like something out of space.
    Remember, space is a new biom and we are trying to create a certain new style/feel for it.
    We ask judges to be open minded for this part of the judging and not hold any stereotypes against people who search for new ideas in their entries.

    Usability:
    How usable is the entry for the Deepworld space spawn?
    Does it have rares? Is it too big? Does it have a clear exit?
    Technically an entry with no rares and of moderate size should be getting 10/10 and 1/10 would be given to an entry full of teslas, control panels and rares.
    I would rate entries as such:
    6-9/10 - if an entry more than one touchplate, or more than one of the items that you could find in dungeons: such as engines, collectors, furnaces and so on.
    5-1/10 If an entry spams engenneering items, or use rares.
    P.S. Keep in mind that entries that win and are considered for use in game might have certain items removed before use, so judges should also keep in mind that if the see a rare in a build that could be replaced and it would not effect the entry very much, they should not mark the entry too harshly. For example if u see a notch in an entry, you can assume it is a landscape and treat it as such for their mark down.

    While we wait, Judges please reread this. It's for STAGE two of judging.
    For each nomination, I ask you to send me the following info:
    EXAMPLE:
    (Entry Number) - C6 O8 S9 U10 T33

    This means - Creativity-6 Originality&Style-8 SpaceLook-9 Usability-10 Total-33

    Thanks!!! :)
    Is it fine if we do...
    Creative & Attractiveness - 6
    Originality & Style - 9
    Space Look = 9
    Usability - 10
    Total - 33

    Also I agree with Emma... we should wait 1 more day.
    We are waiting. :)
  • IronManArcherIronManArcher STEEEEEEEEEEAM JEETSPosts: 2,769Member
    edited March 2018
    /...............................\
    |........11\.12...1.........|
    |....10......\..........2.....|
    |...9.........(•)——..3...|
    |.....8..................4.....|
    |.........7....6....5.........|
    \................................/
  • LilyabcLilyabc Kpop?Posts: 999Member
    Detech said:

    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Detech said:

    Instead of arguing regarding what items should or should not be used, I decided to write down an expanded note for judges (and contestants). Please let me know if you agree or disagree on any parts:

    Judging Space Spawn Competition:
    1-10/10 Creativity & Attractiveness
    1-10/10 Originality & Style
    1-10/10 Space Look
    1-10/10 Usability
    4-40/40 TOTAL

    Creativity & Attractiveness:
    This part of judging depends solely on how much the judge likes your build.
    How creative does the judge think your build is and how much does he like it?

    Originality & Style:
    Does the entry have a certain style to it?
    Does it stand out from the rest? From what you usually see in deepworld?
    Will the entry add something new to deepworld and inspire others to build and create?
    Is there a pattern in the entry, or is it messy?
    Does the style hold throughout the whole entry?

    Space Look:
    Does the entry look like it belongs in space?
    Entries can be out of any material, but should look like something out of space.
    Remember, space is a new biom and we are trying to create a certain new style/feel for it.
    We ask judges to be open minded for this part of the judging and not hold any stereotypes against people who search for new ideas in their entries.

    Usability:
    How usable is the entry for the Deepworld space spawn?
    Does it have rares? Is it too big? Does it have a clear exit?
    Technically an entry with no rares and of moderate size should be getting 10/10 and 1/10 would be given to an entry full of teslas, control panels and rares.
    I would rate entries as such:
    6-9/10 - if an entry more than one touchplate, or more than one of the items that you could find in dungeons: such as engines, collectors, furnaces and so on.
    5-1/10 If an entry spams engenneering items, or use rares.
    P.S. Keep in mind that entries that win and are considered for use in game might have certain items removed before use, so judges should also keep in mind that if the see a rare in a build that could be replaced and it would not effect the entry very much, they should not mark the entry too harshly. For example if u see a notch in an entry, you can assume it is a landscape and treat it as such for their mark down.

    While we wait, Judges please reread this. It's for STAGE two of judging.
    For each nomination, I ask you to send me the following info:
    EXAMPLE:
    (Entry Number) - C6 O8 S9 U10 T33

    This means - Creativity-6 Originality&Style-8 SpaceLook-9 Usability-10 Total-33

    Thanks!!! :)
    Is it fine if we do...
    Creative & Attractiveness - 6
    Originality & Style - 9
    Space Look = 9
    Usability - 10
    Total - 33

    Also I agree with Emma... we should wait 1 more day.
    We are waiting. :)
    So can we do it like that?
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Detech said:

    Instead of arguing regarding what items should or should not be used, I decided to write down an expanded note for judges (and contestants). Please let me know if you agree or disagree on any parts:

    Judging Space Spawn Competition:
    1-10/10 Creativity & Attractiveness
    1-10/10 Originality & Style
    1-10/10 Space Look
    1-10/10 Usability
    4-40/40 TOTAL

    Creativity & Attractiveness:
    This part of judging depends solely on how much the judge likes your build.
    How creative does the judge think your build is and how much does he like it?

    Originality & Style:
    Does the entry have a certain style to it?
    Does it stand out from the rest? From what you usually see in deepworld?
    Will the entry add something new to deepworld and inspire others to build and create?
    Is there a pattern in the entry, or is it messy?
    Does the style hold throughout the whole entry?

    Space Look:
    Does the entry look like it belongs in space?
    Entries can be out of any material, but should look like something out of space.
    Remember, space is a new biom and we are trying to create a certain new style/feel for it.
    We ask judges to be open minded for this part of the judging and not hold any stereotypes against people who search for new ideas in their entries.

    Usability:
    How usable is the entry for the Deepworld space spawn?
    Does it have rares? Is it too big? Does it have a clear exit?
    Technically an entry with no rares and of moderate size should be getting 10/10 and 1/10 would be given to an entry full of teslas, control panels and rares.
    I would rate entries as such:
    6-9/10 - if an entry more than one touchplate, or more than one of the items that you could find in dungeons: such as engines, collectors, furnaces and so on.
    5-1/10 If an entry spams engenneering items, or use rares.
    P.S. Keep in mind that entries that win and are considered for use in game might have certain items removed before use, so judges should also keep in mind that if the see a rare in a build that could be replaced and it would not effect the entry very much, they should not mark the entry too harshly. For example if u see a notch in an entry, you can assume it is a landscape and treat it as such for their mark down.

    While we wait, Judges please reread this. It's for STAGE two of judging.
    For each nomination, I ask you to send me the following info:
    EXAMPLE:
    (Entry Number) - C6 O8 S9 U10 T33

    This means - Creativity-6 Originality&Style-8 SpaceLook-9 Usability-10 Total-33

    Thanks!!! :)
    Is it fine if we do...
    Creative & Attractiveness - 6
    Originality & Style - 9
    Space Look = 9
    Usability - 10
    Total - 33

    Also I agree with Emma... we should wait 1 more day.
    We are waiting. :)
    So can we do it like that?
    Totally fine with me
  • RhinoClawRhinoClaw HellPosts: 143Member
    edited March 2018
    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Detech said:

    Instead of arguing regarding what items should or should not be used, I decided to write down an expanded note for judges (and contestants). Please let me know if you agree or disagree on any parts:

    Judging Space Spawn Competition:
    1-10/10 Creativity & Attractiveness
    1-10/10 Originality & Style
    1-10/10 Space Look
    1-10/10 Usability
    4-40/40 TOTAL

    Creativity & Attractiveness:
    This part of judging depends solely on how much the judge likes your build.
    How creative does the judge think your build is and how much does he like it?

    Originality & Style:
    Does the entry have a certain style to it?
    Does it stand out from the rest? From what you usually see in deepworld?
    Will the entry add something new to deepworld and inspire others to build and create?
    Is there a pattern in the entry, or is it messy?
    Does the style hold throughout the whole entry?

    Space Look:
    Does the entry look like it belongs in space?
    Entries can be out of any material, but should look like something out of space.
    Remember, space is a new biom and we are trying to create a certain new style/feel for it.
    We ask judges to be open minded for this part of the judging and not hold any stereotypes against people who search for new ideas in their entries.

    Usability:
    How usable is the entry for the Deepworld space spawn?
    Does it have rares? Is it too big? Does it have a clear exit?
    Technically an entry with no rares and of moderate size should be getting 10/10 and 1/10 would be given to an entry full of teslas, control panels and rares.
    I would rate entries as such:
    6-9/10 - if an entry more than one touchplate, or more than one of the items that you could find in dungeons: such as engines, collectors, furnaces and so on.
    5-1/10 If an entry spams engenneering items, or use rares.
    P.S. Keep in mind that entries that win and are considered for use in game might have certain items removed before use, so judges should also keep in mind that if the see a rare in a build that could be replaced and it would not effect the entry very much, they should not mark the entry too harshly. For example if u see a notch in an entry, you can assume it is a landscape and treat it as such for their mark down.

    While we wait, Judges please reread this. It's for STAGE two of judging.
    For each nomination, I ask you to send me the following info:
    EXAMPLE:
    (Entry Number) - C6 O8 S9 U10 T33

    This means - Creativity-6 Originality&Style-8 SpaceLook-9 Usability-10 Total-33

    Thanks!!! :)
    Is it fine if we do...
    Creative & Attractiveness - 6
    Originality & Style - 9
    Space Look = 9
    Usability - 10
    Total - 33

    Also I agree with Emma... we should wait 1 more day.
    We are waiting. :)
    So can we do it like that?
    Where's the disagree button?
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    edited March 2018
    If llama doesn't respond before I get home from work, we will go on without him.
    Post edited by Detech on
  • LilyabcLilyabc Kpop?Posts: 999Member
    Detech said:

    If llama doesn't respond before I get home from work, we will go on without him.

    Fair Enough.
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    I picked 12 entries... been thinking which two to eliminate for past half hour :(
    SO HARD! SO MANY GOOD ENTRIES!!!
  • AMWhyAMWhy http://forums.deepworldgame.com/discussion/27517/the-kepler-colony-evacuationPosts: 1,215Member, Arbiter
    I agree, it was hard to limit down to just 10 nominations. However, you should have finished your nominations first. That way you aren't tempted to change your choice after seeing what other entries were nominated...
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    edited March 2018
    NOMINATIONS ARE IN!!!
    An entry had to get 2 nominations from 6 judges to be able to enter into the next round.
    Lets thank our judges for their hard work: @RhinoClaw @Lilyabc @Mofc1991 @AMWhy @emma (and me) :)

    I hope @mikelaurence gets a chance to check out these entries and uses some of them to enrich the new space biom.

    Stage one Judging is complete, now Judges can start dropping judgement on the 18 nominations!!!
    image

    6. E.P.I.C.
    image

    8. Shadowreal
    image

    12. Kacibug03
    image

    14. IronManArcher
    image

    16. FlynnXD
    image

    22. Arcane
    image

    25. Retta
    image

    26. IamNathan
    image

    34. fredwardthegreat
    image

    35. Bastian7
    image

    44. Sir_Adder
    image

    57. NewGuyNow
    image

    60. TealHyena
    image

    61. racerdog
    image

    67. bazzi.
    image

    74. pinky75
    image

    82. Jopjop15
    image

    86. Jonnystyle
    image

    90. Jack.
    image

    99. BigFella
    image
    Post edited by Detech on
    marks.jpg
    439 x 867 - 358K
    6 EPIC.jpg
    1382 x 961 - 817K
    8 shadowreal.jpg
    1121 x 941 - 652K
    12 kacibug03.jpg
    1262 x 1065 - 807K
    14 IronManArcher.jpg
    1262 x 1065 - 596K
    16 FlynnXD.jpg
    839 x 869 - 600K
    22 Arcane.jpg
    1179 x 960 - 633K
    25 Retta.jpg
    1268 x 967 - 1M
    26 iamNathan.jpg
    1150 x 967 - 627K
    34 fredwardthegreat.jpg
    1101 x 931 - 597K
    35 Bastian7.jpg
    1101 x 931 - 648K
    44 Sir Adder.jpg
    880 x 766 - 448K
    57 NewGuyNow.jpg
    1098 x 1134 - 840K
    60 TealHyena.jpg
    920 x 940 - 672K
    61 racerdog.jpg
    1098 x 912 - 351K
    67 bazzi.jpg
    880 x 766 - 460K
    74 pinky75.jpg
    872 x 1076 - 696K
    82 jopjop15.jpg
    1162 x 870 - 830K
    90 jack.jpg
    1070 x 730 - 652K
    99 BigFella.jpg
    858 x 788 - 454K
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    AMWhy said:

    I agree, it was hard to limit down to just 10 nominations. However, you should have finished your nominations first. That way you aren't tempted to change your choice after seeing what other entries were nominated...

    I did do it first. I seen all the entries many times. But I had 12 selected...
    Was going to ask if I could have 12 nominations, cause i didn't want to let go. But I forced myself to let go lol.
  • FlynnXDFlynnXD Posts: 1,231Member
    Tough competition! I'm loving most of the builds that have been nominated! It's like a plethora of building styles, and they're all rocking the "space" theme in their own ways. Excited for the outcome :smiley:
  • IronManArcherIronManArcher STEEEEEEEEEEAM JEETSPosts: 2,769Member
    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!
  • LilyabcLilyabc Kpop?Posts: 999Member
    edited March 2018
    Now the 2nd round I'm assuming? ;w;
    It's going to be really... HARD.
    EDIT: Also Good Luck to those who got nominated!
    Post edited by Lilyabc on
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    Llama wrote back this morning with his list of entries he nominated.
    Since I already posted the nominations and we have enough, I asked him to just judge the nominated entries.
  • LilyabcLilyabc Kpop?Posts: 999Member
    edited March 2018
    Detech said:

    Llama wrote back this morning with his list of entries he nominated.
    Since I already posted the nominations and we have enough, I asked him to just judge the nominated entries.

    Ah so he's back in right?
    EDIT: Realized that it was a stupid question. :3
    Post edited by Lilyabc on
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    Llama wrote back this morning with his list of entries he nominated.
    Since I already posted the nominations and we have enough, I asked him to just judge the nominated entries.

    Ah so he's back in right?
    EDIT: Realized that it was a stupid question. :3
    Actually it's not. I asked him if he wants to judge nominations and now I am waiting for him to respond :)
  • ItsjustketchupItsjustketchup Plastic BeachPosts: 220Member

    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!

    Yours is my favourite, Oh instead of making more then one comment let me just say it all at once this judging thing seems over complicated but I’m lazy to read it all good luck to everyone:P
  • ArcanGraveArcanGrave ArcanGrovePosts: 278Member
    My favourite of all the nominated is @IronManArcher 's crashed ship :)
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member

    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!

    Yours is my favourite, Oh instead of making more then one comment let me just say it all at once this judging thing seems over complicated but I’m lazy to read it all good luck to everyone:P
    Are you sure you don't want to judge? I even took the time to make screenshots to make it easier for judges. It's not complicated... usability is simple, style is understandable, creativity also simple and space look is obvious.
  • LilyabcLilyabc Kpop?Posts: 999Member
    Detech said:

    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!

    Yours is my favourite, Oh instead of making more then one comment let me just say it all at once this judging thing seems over complicated but I’m lazy to read it all good luck to everyone:P
    Are you sure you don't want to judge? I even took the time to make screenshots to make it easier for judges. It's not complicated... usability is simple, style is understandable, creativity also simple and space look is obvious.
    Detech he may not have time to judge?
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    Oh my! I missed one of the screenshots in my nominations post.
    Sorry about that. Here it is (I will add it to the nominations post as well)
    86 jonnystyle.jpg
    1162 x 1066 - 851K
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    I am finished judging. I will send my numbers to the first judge who will be done and sends me marks, that way they could confirm I did not change anything after I got all the judges marks.

    Either way both llama and ketchup are welcome to judge, if they have time.
    Took me about 30 minutes. was much faster than nominating, cause I did not have to decide who to leave out.
  • ItsjustketchupItsjustketchup Plastic BeachPosts: 220Member
    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!

    Yours is my favourite, Oh instead of making more then one comment let me just say it all at once this judging thing seems over complicated but I’m lazy to read it all good luck to everyone:P
    Are you sure you don't want to judge? I even took the time to make screenshots to make it easier for judges. It's not complicated... usability is simple, style is understandable, creativity also simple and space look is obvious.
    Detech he may not have time to judge?
    Nah I’m just lazy and if I was gonna vote I vote for @IronManArcher or however that works
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    2/7 judges are done.
  • IronManArcherIronManArcher STEEEEEEEEEEAM JEETSPosts: 2,769Member
    edited March 2018

    My favourite of all the nominated is IronManArcher's crashed ship :)

    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!

    Yours is my favourite, Oh instead of making more then one comment let me just say it all at once this judging thing seems over complicated but I’m lazy to read it all good luck to everyone:P
    Are you sure you don't want to judge? I even took the time to make screenshots to make it easier for judges. It's not complicated... usability is simple, style is understandable, creativity also simple and space look is obvious.
    Detech he may not have time to judge?
    Nah I’m just lazy and if I was gonna vote I vote for IronManArcher or however that works
    Yay!
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member

    My favourite of all the nominated is IronManArcher's crashed ship :)

    Lilyabc said:

    Detech said:

    There are no spiders in space! Whoops!

    Yours is my favourite, Oh instead of making more then one comment let me just say it all at once this judging thing seems over complicated but I’m lazy to read it all good luck to everyone:P
    Are you sure you don't want to judge? I even took the time to make screenshots to make it easier for judges. It's not complicated... usability is simple, style is understandable, creativity also simple and space look is obvious.
    Detech he may not have time to judge?
    Nah I’m just lazy and if I was gonna vote I vote for IronManArcher or however that works
    Yay!
    Iron, the judge who likes your entry is too lazy to judge. You should be sad.
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    edited March 2018
    Reposting this again for judges:
    @RhinoClaw @Lilyabc @blunt_Llama @Emma.
    @Mofc1991 @Detech @AMWhy

    Judging Space Spawn Competition:
    1-10/10 Creativity & Attractiveness
    1-10/10 Originality & Style
    1-10/10 Space Look
    1-10/10 Usability
    4-40/40 TOTAL

    Creativity & Attractiveness:
    This part of judging depends solely on how much the judge likes your build.
    How creative does the judge think your build is and how much does he like it?

    Originality & Style:
    Does the entry have a certain style to it?
    Does it stand out from the rest? From what you usually see in deepworld?
    Will the entry add something new to deepworld and inspire others to build and create?
    Is there a pattern in the entry, or is it messy?
    Does the style hold throughout the whole entry?

    Space Look:
    Does the entry look like it belongs in space?
    Entries can be out of any material, but should look like something out of space.
    Remember, space is a new biom and we are trying to create a certain new style/feel for it.
    We ask judges to be open minded for this part of the judging and not hold any stereotypes against people who search for new ideas in their entries.

    Usability:
    How usable is the entry for the Deepworld space spawn?
    Does it have rares? Is it too big? Does it have a clear exit?
    Technically an entry with no rares and of moderate size should be getting 10/10 and 1/10 would be given to an entry full of teslas, control panels and rares.
    I would rate entries as such:
    6-9/10 - if an entry more than one touchplate, or more than one of the items that you could find in dungeons: such as engines, collectors, furnaces and so on.
    5-1/10 If an entry spams engenneering items, or use rares.
    P.S. Keep in mind that entries that win and are considered for use in game might have certain items removed before use, so judges should also keep in mind that if the see a rare in a build that could be replaced and it would not effect the entry very much, they should not mark the entry too harshly. For example if u see a notch in an entry, you can assume it is a landscape and treat it as such for their mark down.
  • DetechDetech Toronto, CanadaPosts: 2,007Member
    Any more judges done their duties?
  • AMWhyAMWhy http://forums.deepworldgame.com/discussion/27517/the-kepler-colony-evacuationPosts: 1,215Member, Arbiter
    Nearly - I'll get results to you in a few hours.
Sign In or Register to comment.